Markus Schmidt, Europe region analyst at Worldwise Analytica

Markus Schmidt

Analyzing Today, Anticipating Tomorrow

Europe on the Brink: U.S.-Russia Negotiations Undermine NATO, Economic Crisis Deepens, and Russian Hybrid Warfare Intensifies

The Trump administration’s decision to refuse co-sponsorship of a U.N. resolution supporting Ukraine’s territorial integrity is a game-changer. This move, combined with Trump’s direct talks with Moscow, signals that Washington is no longer aligned with Europe in its approach to Russia. The refusal to use past language condemning ‘Russian aggression’ in G7 statements further underscores a fundamental shift in U.S. policy. European leaders now fear that the U.S. is preparing to pressure Ukraine into territorial concessions that will undermine NATO’s long-term strategic position in Eastern Europe.

Macron and Starmer are leading European resistance to Trump’s unilateralism. Macron is set to visit Washington in a last-ditch effort to convince Trump that European security is tied to U.S. credibility on Ukraine, warning that appeasing Russia will embolden China and Iran. Meanwhile, British Prime Minister Keir Starmer is pushing a NATO peacekeeping proposal for Ukraine, a move that has provoked strong Kremlin opposition. Russia’s warnings that NATO troops in Ukraine would be considered a ‘direct threat’ raise the stakes for European security policy.

The EU is struggling to formulate a coherent response as internal divisions mount. While Estonia and other Eastern European states demand a stronger NATO posture, Germany remains hesitant, fearing economic retaliation from Russia. Berlin’s political turmoil, exacerbated by the AfD’s growing influence and allegations of foreign funding, further weakens Germany’s ability to lead Europe’s response to the crisis.

The U.S.-EU trade war is escalating into a full-fledged economic confrontation. Trump’s administration is now refusing to negotiate tariff exemptions, with European car manufacturers and agricultural exporters facing mounting losses. Germany’s economic woes, compounded by Trump’s tariffs and internal fiscal struggles, risk triggering a deeper recession across the Eurozone. With investor confidence plummeting, European policymakers face the urgent task of countering U.S. economic pressure while maintaining political stability.

Russia is intensifying hybrid warfare across Europe. Cyberattacks on Italian financial institutions, disinformation campaigns in Germany, and suspected sabotage targeting oil tankers in the Mediterranean all point to Moscow’s growing efforts to destabilize the EU. The terrorism investigation into the explosion of the Seajewel tanker off Italy raises concerns that Russia or its proxies are engaging in asymmetric warfare to disrupt European energy security.

The Kremlin is openly backing Trump in his public disputes with Zelenskiy, portraying Ukraine’s leader as an obstacle to peace. Russian officials have praised Trump’s calls for Ukraine to cede territory in exchange for a deal, reinforcing fears that the U.S. and Russia are converging on a settlement that fundamentally reshapes European security without European input.

Ukraine’s energy sector remains a primary target of Russian aggression. The latest wave of missile and drone strikes has crippled Ukrainian gas production, forcing Kyiv to increase emergency energy imports. With winter still ongoing, the humanitarian and economic impact of these attacks is worsening, increasing pressure on Europe to provide emergency energy assistance.

Greenland’s independence debate is emerging as a new geopolitical flashpoint. The ruling Inuit Ataqatigiit party is facing pressure from pro-independence factions to accelerate the process, particularly in light of renewed U.S. strategic interest in the Arctic. Any move towards secession would have major implications for NATO’s Arctic strategy and could alter European energy security dynamics.

Europe faces an unprecedented convergence of geopolitical, economic, and security threats. The decisions made in the coming weeks will determine whether the continent can assert its strategic autonomy or remain at the mercy of shifting U.S. and Russian priorities.

Geopolitical Risk Assessment for the Europe
(21-02-2025)

Europe faces a watershed moment as the Trump administration moves towards an agreement with Russia, bypassing European security concerns and potentially forcing Ukraine into a disadvantageous settlement. The deepening U.S.-EU trade war is exacerbating economic instability, while Russian hybrid warfare continues to escalate. Political uncertainty in Germany, Austria, and Romania signals growing instability within the EU, which is further challenged by an energy crisis caused by continued Russian attacks on Ukrainian infrastructure. With NATO debating a peacekeeping presence in Ukraine and the Kremlin openly backing Trump in his disputes with Zelenskiy, Europe must decide how to assert its strategic autonomy before the geopolitical landscape shifts irrevocably.

Geopolitical Risk Index

Developments to Follow for the Europe (See All Global)